On the Thursday before Lehigh-Lafayette, Molly’s Irish Grille and Sports Pub hangs a 4-foot stuffed leopard from the ceiling with the help of a Lehigh student.
On game day, a group of alumni fraternity brothers who have returned for The Rivalry for decades picks up food from Campus Pizza before heading to the pregame tailgate.
Some of South Bethlehem’s game-day traditions date back to when fans could walk from their favorite restaurants to Taylor Stadium.
Other traditions are just getting started.
At the Donerds Donuts food truck, students can pick up a coffee and doughnut before catching the bus to the game.
A home base for alumni
Gia Heaton, manager of Molly’s, said game day is one of the busiest days of the year for the pub.
“It’s one of our biggest days as far as volume and sales, but it’s also one of our most prideful,” she said.
Throughout the week, the pub offers food specials and sells game-day shirts.
On game day, employees dress up in Lehigh gear, and the game is displayed on every screen, with extra staff scheduled to handle the rowdy crowd.
“We really try to let people know what Molly’s represents,” Heaton said. “We want people to know that we root for the boys.”
Heaton said some alumni return with their families for the game.
She described the pub as a “home base” for people returning to Bethlehem, and said on game day, she can feel the community strength and pride for Lehigh in the air.
Pre-game Doughnuts from Donerds
When Lafayette hosts The Rivalry, the Donerds Donuts food truck sets up near the bus pickup, allowing students to get breakfast before leaving for the game.
When Lehigh hosts, students can stop for doughnuts and coffee as they head to Goodman Stadium.
Andrew Underwood, co-owner of Donerds Donuts, estimates the truck hands out about 500 free doughnuts on game day morning, sponsored by a partnership with Lehigh.
“It’s early in the morning, so people are excited, a little sleepy, but also excited to get caffeine and a free doughnut,” Underwood said.
Donerds has operated its food truck since 2021, and the business has worked with the university since the opening of their local shop in 2023.
Underwood and his wife, who own the business together, are happy to take on events that bring them together with Lehigh students.
“It gives our work a true meaning,” Underwood said,
The weekend looks different at the storefront on East Fourth Street.
Donerds makes custom Lehigh-themed doughnuts, and Underwood said there’s a notable rise in traffic and sales during The Rivalry, particularly when Lehigh hosts.
A tailgate stop at Campus Pizza
Before the Farrington Square apartments went up behind Campus Pizza, fans would tailgate in the parking lots there.
Angelo Caiazzo, co-owner of Campus Pizza, said he remembers large crowds gathering across the street from the restaurant and walking to Taylor Stadium for the game.
“I mean, the whole community was involved,” Caiazzo said.
Caiazzo’s father opened Campus Pizza in 1979.
The location of the Le-Laf game still affects how busy they are, Caiazzo said, with more customers when Lehigh hosts.
His brother came up with their popular Le-Laf T-shirt that hangs from the counter about three or four years ago.
Caiazzo said it serves as a symbol of the community’s spirit and willingness to pick fun of the opponent.
For one group of about 50 to 60 fraternity brothers from the 1980s and ‘90s, Campus Pizza is an essential stop before the tailgate.
Caiazzo said they come back for The Rivalry, pick up food and then head to the game.
He said seeing those alumni again is one of his favorite parts of the weekend.
Familiar faces at The Goose
When a customer ordered the “Incredible Bulk” sandwich during The Rivalry last year at the Goosey Gander Deli, co-owner Tony Silvoy thought of the Lehigh linebacker who used to order the same sandwich in the early 1980s.
Silvoy, who grew up on the South Side, remembers fans marching down Taylor Street with pieces of the goalpost after games at Taylor Stadium.
“The bigger the piece, the bigger the cheer you got,” Silvoy said.
At the deli, part of game day for Silvoy is seeing old friends who return for The Rivalry.
He said he’s happy to keep making the sandwiches customers have grown to love.
Some come in asking whether they can still get the sandwiches they remember from years ago.
When alumni come back for The Rivalry, Silvoy said, they often remark on how much the school and surrounding area have changed since they were students.
“In here, they feel like nothing’s changed,” Silvoy said. “They walk in, and everything at The Goose remains just the same.”
From the parking lots where fans once tailgated to the counters where they still place their orders, The Rivalry continues to bring generations of Lehigh fans back to South Bethlehem.



Comment Policy
Comments posted to The Brown and White website are reviewed by a moderator before being approved. Incendiary speech or harassing language, including comments targeted at individuals, may be deemed unacceptable and not published. Spam and other soliciting will also be declined.
The Brown and White also reserves the right to refuse the publication of entirely anonymous comments.