Edit desk: Dear Lehigh, you’ve changed


Catherine Manthorp

I remember the backyards engulfed by canopies of lights that strung above us, creating our own sky, and the music that would play, not so loud that it was obnoxious but not so soft that it would put us to sleep.

I remember the groups of people mingling and socializing under the stars, having genuinely good times and forming relationships that would remain in the morning and every day after. These people had come sober, for the most part, and now held cups in their hands, taking sips every so often. They spent the majority of their time chatting and showing sincere interest in what others had to say.

I remember feeling so safe that I could walk home alone if I wanted to. I would pass police officers along the way who would motion to me with a wave to make sure I was OK, or who would let fraternity brothers know if a party was getting too out-of-hand, cracking jokes about their own rowdy college memories in the process.

I remember a time when people actually enjoyed themselves at parties without blacking out.

The transition away from this light-hearted culture happened so gradually that I didn’t even notice it at first, but sure enough, the early days of my college experience are long gone.

When I was a freshman, I didn’t realize how substantial of a problem alcohol would be on college campuses across the nation, especially closer to home in Lehigh’s bubble.

Now, alcohol is the cause of multiple students’ deaths, including Timothy Piazza of Penn State University and McCrae Williams of Lafayette College in Pennsylvania alone.

It’s the reason it seems there’s been so many more hospitalizations this semester than in past years.

As a senior, I can’t remember the last time I went to an off-campus party I actually enjoyed.

At recent parties, I’ve been herded into pitch-black, scorching basements like a sheep where I remember feeling suffocated. Music was always blaring as bodies moved to the beat. No one was talking — only yelling. The faint smell of vomit usually lingered in the background as all around, people would chug and take shots.

“Shut the f— up!” fraternity brothers would scream whenever cops drove by, eventually quieting everyone down. The second the car passed, the party would rage on.

I remember nights like these very clearly, but ask anyone else who was there. I’m willing to bet entire segments of time would be missing from many dim recollections of these parties.

I’ve taken care of these people. They would bounce in and out of consciousness, unable to hold up their limp bodies as their eyes occasionally fluttered open.

I’ve also been taken care of.

I’ve fallen into the same cycle so many others have, never realizing until now there was a cycle to begin with. One that could hold me and everyone else captive.

There have been too many close calls with too many people. Too little has been done to change this.

I never want to wake up and read the news to see a student death headline — this time from Lehigh. There are so many opportunities to act as catalysts for change, yet nothing seems to happen unless tragedy strikes first.

It feels like overnight, social drinking was out and binge drinking was in.

Taking more shots than your limit allows. Puking and rallying. Waking up the morning after to not remember the night before. It was all in.

Lehigh has so many great qualities. I’ve been taught by some of the most passionate professors I’ve ever met. I’ve found my calling. I’ve taken on leadership roles I never thought I was capable of. I’ve found an organization of best friends that I can call home.

Yet, somehow, all roads seem to lead back to alcohol.

That wasn’t always the case. And it isn’t what should define our college experiences and our Lehigh memories.

I’m leaving you, Lehigh, a different place than I found you.

Catherine Manthorp, ’18, is the deputy sports editor for The Brown and White. She can be reached at [email protected].

Comment policy

Comments posted to The Brown and White website are reviewed by a moderator before being approved. Incendiary speech or harassing language, including comments targeted at individuals, may be deemed unacceptable and not published. Spam and other soliciting will also be declined.

The Brown and White also reserves the right to not publish entirely anonymous comments.


  1. Brice Haines ‘67 on

    Nice article Catherine talking about the difference of social drinking vs binge drinking. Lehigh of my era was mostly social drinking at fraternity houses with the hill closed off for traffic & live bands at 1/3 of the 30 fraternity houses every Saturday night. Social drinking took place only on Saturday night in that era with occasional whales tales participants Friday night for the liberal arts majors that didn’t have Saturday classes.

  2. When will Lehigh and its clueless administration get the message that zero-tolerance and excessive, brutal enforcement of drinking laws and targeting its own students not only does not solve the problem of binge drinking, it EXACERBATES it?

    It is very enlightening to read the following article about Lehigh’s hard-nosed, unapologetic enforcement, comparing it to other Lehigh Valley colleges:


    Note our illustrious new Vice Provost of Student Affairs Ricardo Hall’s quote: “What I hear again and again is the university doesn’t want us to party. And I’ve made it very clear. If you aren’t 21, you aren’t going to be permitted to drink.” Milk-and-cookie socials, anyone? Hall seems astutely aware of what young adults REALLY want to do for a good time. Apparently no one told the students!

    In contrast, consider the approach taken by DeSales University, as reflected in the following story:


    ““Our approach is not out to get students, ours is to help students,” said Jen Bunting, the assistant dean of students for campus life and student conduct.”

    There is no doubt Lehigh is out to get its own students. Ricardo Hall clearly does not understand Lehigh or its culture, or apparently the culture of any other college (except for maybe BYU). It’s Hall and the rest of the administration against 2/3 of the student body. Will they be satisfied after everyone has been arrested? Will that get everyone to stop drinking? Highly doubtful. It seems the problem of binge drinking at Lehigh has gotten worse since the crackdown, not better. But if that is the type of creative thinking that got Hall hired at Lehigh, the search committee was dumber than I thought, and it doesn’t bode well for Lehigh’s future. No parent in their right mind will send their kid to Lehigh when they find out the school has absolutely no qualms about making sure their kids are arrested if caught doing what the majority of 18-20 year-old college students do nationwide. Short of prohibition, this statistic will likely not change. Like it or not, it’s part of growing up. Lehigh, in conjunction with other colleges and universities, should use its resources to get the law changed to lower the drinking age back to 18 where it belongs, as it is in the majority of the civilized world. Bring college drinking back out into the open, and concentrate on ABUSE, rather than on enforcement.

    SHAME ON YOU, LEHIGH!!! You are so much better than this!

    • Amy Charles '89 on


      I was at Lehigh long before zero-tolerance. You could be a child and get served. And I covered drunk deaths for DI, hazing nightmares. Profs rolled in drunk sometimes. If you were prone to alcoholism, the Hill was a wonderful place to find that out. Everyone learned about how you turned a drunk, passed-out friend on his or her side so s/he didn’t wind up choking on vomit. The *official* drinking schedule, Panhel-office-produced, ran Weds night (pubnight) to Sat night (grain alcohol dance parties, electric jello), but apparently we also needed sunrise cocktails, tailgates, wine & cheeses with alcoholic faculty, and the sousing that was Greek Week. Unsurprisingly, the Hill was a haven for sexual abuse, too.

      You have no idea what you’re talking about.

Leave A Reply