Column: Columbus Day — A source of contention


We recently marked the 83rd Columbus Day in the United States. The day became a federal holiday in 1937, and while this day may come and go without much thought for many people, where I come from, it’s one of the most divisive days of the year. 

I live in northern New Jersey where an obvious majority of the population is of Italian descent. I grew up with friends whose parents invited me over for Sunday “gravy” (marinara) and meatballs. Words like “gabagool” and “super-sod” are just part of the vocabulary. 

Unsurprisingly, the town I went to high school in holds a Columbus Day parade each year where people from the area come to boast their Italian heritage and march past the statue of Christopher Columbus that stands on the main street of town. 

As a kid, I never thought twice about Columbus Day. In elementary school, we were told that he “discovered America” and that “In 1492 Columbus sailed the ocean blue.” My parents would explain that this wasn’t entirely true and was an oversimplification of history.

In high school, my teachers basically had to “debunk” the Christopher Columbus myth. They explained how he terrorized the indigenous people who really “discovered” America and explained how even the word “discovered” is inherently patronizing. 

I’d always been aware of the resistance to Columbus Day. I read articles every year in protest of the holiday about cultural appropriation, the disregard for indigenous people and the perpetuation of white heroism, but the negative sentiments about Columbus Day really escalated in my area this past summer. 

After George Floyd’s murder, protesters started to tear down statues of Christopher Columbus in various parts of the country to take a stand against white supremacy. 

Many people from my high school took to social media in support of tearing the statue in our area down. This was a pretty shocking moment for our community. Since the Italian-American population is so overwhelming, students who don’t identify with that culture tend to silently dismiss the ignorance, knowing they’ll lose the battle anyway. 

No one had ever been brave enough to point out that this Italian-American pride had become outright racism. Students at school wrote on ceiling tiles, “Diversity” and drew an Italian flag and an American flag. There was an instance of an Italian-American girl calling a black girl the “n” word during my time there. Over the summer, many students shared their stories of the discrimination they faced while attending my high school. Many Muslim girls shared ignorant remarks people made about their hijabs and students of the LGBTQ+ community mentioned how they were called faggots in middle school. 

It had come to the point that even the thought of the Christopher Columbus statue left a sour taste in people’s mouths. Enough was enough. The protests that occurred after George Floyd’s death gave people the strength to point out what was wrong in their own communities and thankfully this dialogue was finally opened in mine. 

Unfortunately, the statue in my neighboring town still stands. The scariest part is that there’s no shame or embarrassment coming from the supporters of keeping the Columbus statue. Knowing what they know about Christopher Columbus, many Italian-Americans still embrace him and the evils he represents because there’s power in claiming ownership of this country. 

What concerns me the most about leaving that statue standing is that it encourages people to hide the truth to get ahead. The truth is marginalized groups have done so much to build this country that white men have laid claim to. People of color, women, and the LGBTQ+ community have held themselves to the same standards of success as white men, even with the cards stacked against them.

I cannot ignore the hypocrisy that has been divulged from this dispute either. Where are their capitalist principles now? What happened to earning their way to the top? What happened to giving credit where credit is due? 

It’s become obvious that the American dream simply excludes marginalized groups entirely. Values and rules that apply to white men suddenly change in the wake of the inevitable rise of the disadvantaged. By allowing this standard of hypocrisy, we’re preventing the majority from succeeding and contributing to the society we all pledge allegiance to. 

The 2020 election will determine the future for these groups. It will determine whether or not we embrace the truth and whether or not justice will be served. It’s time to give credit where credit is due and hold people accountable for not only showing disrespect and hate for their fellow Americans, but for rejecting the principles of the country they claim: life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. 

Comment policy

Comments posted to The Brown and White website are reviewed by a moderator before being approved. Incendiary speech or harassing language, including comments targeted at individuals, may be deemed unacceptable and not published. Spam and other soliciting will also be declined.

The Brown and White also reserves the right to not publish entirely anonymous comments.


  1. It’s amazing how our society has always needed to symbolically lift people up at the expense of others. It has never been “we are all in this together’ as many, now, like to say. It has always been viewed as something being ‘given’ to someone else at the expense of others. Columbus Day was created as means to help lift up people of Italian descent, as they were severely discriminated against since the great European migration began in the late 1800’s. But, making false idols of our ‘leaders’ carries a heavy price. Once we recognize them as nothing more than fellow human beings, might we be able to work together to help them, as well as us, succeed.

  2. Columbus hate has finally made its way to Northern Jersey. Columbus shouldn’t represent Italians in the United States. Columbus should be considered a great explorer who not only opened trade around the world but provided a bridge to both halves of the world. Your right he didn’t discover the United States nor was he the first person there. There was Chinese and possibly African explorers before him. The difference between Columbus and these others were that he shared the information. Unlike your greedy Chinese who hold back information so they can control all aspects. Columbus created a path for open trade around the world. Do you know why Columbus’s statue is in the park? Because he was a great explorer. Not because you eat gabagool in north jersey and pretend to be apart of the Sopranos.

Leave A Reply