Editorial: Too little too late

3

We are seeing, time and time again, Lehigh’s administration deflect responsibility and refuse to take action until it’s too late. 

But now, it’s causing concern for public safety. 

According to the Lehigh COVID-19 dashboard, since Jan. 1 there have been a total of 430 positive cases of coronavirus among students living on and off campus. During the first week of classes,104 students tested positive, and during the second week, 272 more students joined them. 

This rise in cases in such a short period of time is nothing short of obscene. 

It is evident that students have not been following Lehigh’s social contract to social distance and limit social interactions to 10 people or less. 

However, as much as it is the fault of students for being irresponsible, going to large unmasked gatherings, and spreading the virus, the responsibility also falls on the university to put tangible policy in place to penalize students for failure to adhere to rules and regulations. 

This past semester started out by only testing students who chose the campus access option twice within the first two weeks of the semester. And for a while, there were no active cases of COVID-19 on or off campus, which the school made sure to boast about on its social media regularly. However, it is easy to have a low case count when there is little to no testing occurring.

And when the inevitable outbreak did occur, Lehigh closed its campus for two weeks, wasting the money of those who opted to pay for access to campus.

This semester students were required to show a negative test upon arrival, follow a moderated quarantine before classes began and partake in weekly testing for the first two weeks of the semester. After the initial two week testing period, 50 percent of students were planned to be tested each week. 

This new method quickly proved ineffective. Within just two weeks, the case count more than tripled the 100 mark that shut down campus the semester prior. 

The university administration knows that the majority of the infection occurs through off-campus social interactions, yet little is being done to inhibit students from attending such events.

There has been no protocol to check if students randomly selected for surveillance testing actually show up for their test, and there have been few reports of off-campus gatherings getting shut down by the police. 

If students see no consequences for violating social contract, it can’t be expected that they will alter their hazardous behavior. 

Lehigh’s suggestion? Anonymously report your friends. 

While many students have turned to anonymous reporting, the method has proven ineffective as Lehigh sits with more active cases than universities with student bodies five times its size. 

The egregious mishandling of COVID-19 is only amplified by the hypocrisy that exists within Lehigh’s athletic department.

Throughout the various outbreaks that occurred last semester, athletics have continuously been paused and restarted, to only be paused again. When a player tests positive, they are put on a pause for a small, indefinite amount of time, unless it’s a sport like basketball, where everybody is considered a close contact.

But on multiple occasions, athletics have been able to resume 24 hours after a reported outbreak, despite potential incubation time ranging from three to 14 days

Athletics were temporarily shut down on Sept. 29, when Lehigh first spiked in positive cases. 

When Lehigh had less than 100 cases, the majority of campus activity was shut down or scaled back. Yet, when Lehigh has 368 cases, what do we do? Stay open, have sports and continue in-person classes. 

Lehigh wrestling’s match scheduled for Feb. 14 was canceled due to the spike in COVID-19 cases on Bucknell’s campus. Bucknell has only 112 active cases.

Universities like Bucknell prove that the mitigation of COVID-19, in a comparable university to Lehigh, is possible. Last semester, Bucknell’s outbreak peaked at a mere 26 cases. Muhlenberg College saw only 23 positive cases and Lafayette, only 36. 

Lehigh cannot continue to wait for inevitable outbreaks to make changes. They cannot deflect all responsibility onto the students, but they can do a better job of holding them accountable. 

Whether it be stronger planning or fostering a student body who is more willing to adhere to rules and regulations, it is time Lehigh takes a page out of the planning books of its peers. Our inability to handle COVID-19 is not only an embarrassment, but serves as a serious hazard to students, professors and the entire Bethlehem community. 

Comment policy


Comments posted to The Brown and White website are reviewed by a moderator before being approved. Incendiary speech or harassing language, including comments targeted at individuals, may be deemed unacceptable and not published. Spam and other soliciting will also be declined.

The Brown and White also reserves the right to not publish entirely anonymous comments.

3 Comments

  1. Robert Davenport on

    Lehigh may be an Alma Mater but it is not Mommy or Daddy. Grow up children. Same goes for so called adults who politicize protective health actions.

  2. No mention of Greek Life? Whatsoever?

    Lehigh’s testing and mitigation protocols are lacking, even despite improvements made from the previous semester. This is a fair criticism. However, I find it grossly irresponsible to assume that students bear zero responsibility in mitigating what is the scariest prevalence of COVID-19 this campus has yet seen.

    To what extent can Lehigh discourage or punish social gatherings of which they have no knowledge? The reason that current policing has presently failed is through no fault of the university, but rather, those actively and passively complicit in disregarding it. I’m not sure what more Lehigh can do, save threat of explusion, to deter these super-spreader events that continue as if the pandemic had faded into memory. No, at some point we must put our heads down and accept some guilt.

    A little humility would go a long way for the Lehigh’s student body. I, myself, have been slow to accept the reality that a pandemic is raging on, and that changes in behavior are requisite. With no such realization, promises of in-person events near the semester’s end grow increasingly fantastical.

    This is a difficult reality to accept. We’re stuck in a situation where good actors will likely go unrewarded and bad ones unpunished. That is, unless we accept the collective challenge of holding our fellow students accountable. For the sake of our community, our fellow students, and ultimately, our own consciences, I hope we do.

  3. Robert Davenport on

    Senior Student, great answer. “good actors will likely go unrewarded and bad ones unpunished” is a great quote. The Covid-19 reality is responsibility not rights you get an A for this.

Leave A Reply

More in Opinion
Edit Desk: Journal full of memories

At the beginning of quarantine, I started a journal. In the pages of my lavender Moleskin notebook, I crammed in...

Close